Living Accountability: The Cultural Roots of Governance and Utu in Kenya.
“Living Accountability” reflects the idea that social accountability (SAcc)
is rooted in the lived experiences, beliefs, and values of ordinary citizens. It
emphasizes that accountability is not imposed from above but emerges from
communities themselves, shaped by their collective understanding of governance
and justice. The culture of SAcc in Kenya has undergone a remarkable
transformation over the years, shaped by historical moments, political shifts,
and the resilience of its people, from the deeply embedded communal practices
of pre-colonial societies, where governance was rooted in consensus and the utu
philosophy, to the early years of independence when civic consciousness was
overshadowed by state control. The journey has been one of struggle, resistance,
and reinvention.
During the regimes of Jomo Kenyatta and Daniel Arap Moi, SAcc was
systematically suppressed through dictatorship, state violence, and an intolerance
for dissent. Yet, even in those times, pockets of resistance – activists, underground
movements, and progressive leaders, kept the spirit of accountability alive. The
push for constitutional reform under President Mwai Kibaki signalled a turning
point, anchoring governance in participatory democracy, human rights, and
the rule of law. The 2010 Constitution, hailed as one of the most progressive
in Africa, sought to institutionalize transparency, public participation, and the
principles of good governance enshrined in Article 10.
However, under President Uhuru Kenyatta’s administration, civic vigilance
declined noticeably, as many assumed the Constitution alone would safeguard
democracy. This trust was betrayed by a leadership that subverted the law
for personal and political gain. In response, a few institutions, including
TISA and Katiba Institute, remained steadfast in defending constitutionalism
through strategic litigation and advocacy. TISA, focusing on transparency
and accountability, and Katiba Institute, a legal research and advocacy
organization, played crucial roles in upholding the Constitution and challenging
unconstitutional actions.
Today, SAcc has evolved into a digital movement characterized by sophisticated,
artistic, and highly engaging online activism. The 2024 Gen Z-led protests in
Kenya have demonstrated a shift, bringing SAcc back to its roots in national
values and the collective demand for good governance. The young people (Gen
Z’s) demands were not regime change but a structural norm shift that places
the public good above individual power. This shift involved a call for more
transparency in government operations, a reduction in corruption, and a greater
focus on public welfare. They called out wastage, rejected the arrogance of the
political class, demanded justice for corrupt leaders, and insisted on governance
rooted in utu – the full realization of the Constitution’s letter and spirit.
This research illuminates the historical trajectory of SAcc in Kenya, providing
critical insights into its endurance, reinvention, and role in shaping governance.
More importantly, it offers guidance for the Attorney General and Parliament’s
ongoing development of public participation legislative frameworks. As we
move forward, we recognize that democratic governance and sustainable
development are only possible through cultural reengineering – a process driven
by the actions of citizens themselves. In many ways, this is a profoundly Pan-
African struggle, echoing the calls of past and present leaders who have fought
for justice, dignity, and self-determination.
As Wanjira, a youth leader of our times, said, “When we lose our fear, they
lose their power.” The culture of SAcc is thus driven by the need to power
the priorities of citizens through actions such as protests, petitions, and voting,
and voices that the ruling class cannot ignore, including those of civil society
organizations, media, and individual citizens.
We hope this research will serve as a compass for governance in Kenya and
beyond.
Diana Gichengo
Executive Director,
The Institute for Social Accountability (TISA)
Download the full report here: